This continues the archive of retired or unproduced IP, and the stories that accompany them.You can click on the buttons to download the scripts and pitches, using the code CFX to open the locked PDF files.
This one was huge. Early in 2020 I was packing to fly to New Zealand with producer Neil Zeiger. We were heading out to meet with film commissioners, to scout locations, and to begin putting together a diverse writing team appropriate to our subject. The subject was the historic meeting of two cultures, told from multiple points of view instead of the usual colonial perspective. Our base would be Aotearoa but our theatre would be spread all across the Southern Pacific.
I had a tin of Kendal Mint Cake to give to the Maori King. I mean, major diplomacy.
Then Covid closed the borders, and everything went on hold.
It had begun when I was asked for my take on the life of Captain James Cook. Right away my research suggested that there was a bigger, bolder, more faceted and largely untold story there, and that became my pitch. It blossomed into a 10-hour epic in which Cook would feature as one of the players in a much wider and more layered Pacific drama.
Lockdown was a setback. We lost ground but we regrouped. Ultimately the core team was Neil and myself along with veteran NZ producer John (Whale Rider) Barnett and director Lee (Once Were Warriors, Die Another Day) Tamahori.
Click on the button and you’ll see my detailed treatment. This was the show’s foundation document; concept, teaser, main characters and full narrative blueprint for a ten-hour season of period TV. I was aware of being a European, an outsider; Lee, of Maori heritage, didn’t see that as a concern. I knew it wasn’t my personal tale to tell but my aim was to be the builder of a framework into which other, more directly connected voices could be invited for the telling. To establish the material’s factual credentials I took the unusual step of colour-coding the text; what little I had to invent stands out in blue, while everything else is from the historical record.
The setbacks did for us in the end. Our time ran out. The backer of Neil’s company pulled out of the film business, causing a new delay while Neil negotiated to keep the project rights. Then John Barnett died in August 2025. I didn’t see it coming. I see now that he was 80, though from his energy you’d never have guessed it. Lee Tamahori died three months later, not long after returning from the festival circuit for his final movie The Convert (starring Guy Pearce, and recommended).
Well, that was it. I donated my research library to Oxfam books. Made them four hundred quid, at last count.
Developed for Simon Maxwell at Red Arrow, this was a true-life South Africa story pitched to a meeting of the heads of Fox International Channels in LA and subsequently to FX. “When a mugger in a Johannesburg air terminal picks the wrong man to steal from, the act sets off a chain of international consequences leading to the exposure and jailing of the massively corrupt head of Interpol, the world’s leading organisation of police forces.” It’s quite the tale and had we gone ahead, I’d have been pushing for Pierce Brosnan for the role of former MI6 agent Paul O’Sullivan. it’s a story that involves blackmail, terror, murder, home invasion, armed robbery, gangland execution, and a crack police investigative unit with a cool name. Airport crime is only the tip of the iceberg. The trail will lead O’Sullivan to the highest levels of international politics, to those who seized every advantage on offer as they stood in Nelson Mandela’s reflected glory. It ends in triumph for O’Sullivan with Jackie Selebi, Chief of Police and head of the world’s most famous global security organisation, facing fifteen years in jail.
Based on research gathered by Tendeka Matatu and Ralph Ziman from a comprehensive range of sources including court records, witness statements, email exchanges, phone recordings, contemporary reporting, and O’Sullivan’s own dossier.
The recent Paramount+ adaptation of Treasure Island brought this one to mind. Sky had enjoyed success with a rather decent adaptation of Stevenson’s novel with (then) Eddie Izzard in the role of Long John Silver. They wanted a follow-up, and Izzard was keen to reprise the role. Producers Kindle Entertainment optioned Andrew Motion’s novel Silver and asked me to take a swing at it.
I picked up a copy and hit the first snag. I wrote: “If the aim is to produce a sequel to Treasure Island with Eddie Izzard at the heart of it, then the character’s almost complete absence from the novel—appearing only once at the beginning, blind, decrepit, and dying—is, to say the least, an obstacle to adaptation.”
In Silver, the Memo you can see my analysis and first thoughts on how to move forward. And, how you can solve a problem like no Silver. As ever, CFX to unlock the protected file.
This led to meetings, pitch drafts, and notes flying back and forth. At the time Kindle’s offices were on the upper floor of a brick building in the middle of Hackney City Farm and meetings there were always a delight. Money was spent, effort was invested, problems were addressed, and then at that point Sky decided that they weren’t inclined to a sequel after all.
Izzard was still on board, though, and the process began of trying to place the project elsewhere. Always a disheartening task, made harder when you like the people because walking away would feel like a betrayal. But a challenging sell was made even harder by it being a sequel to someone else’s show.
Eventually Izzard moved on, and so did we all.
Sometime around 2004 Rupert Murdoch’s Sky TV (again) made it known that they were looking for ‘a British Buffy’. Every production company in town kicked into gear and Carnival passed the challenge to me. After three seasons of BUGS and the Oktober miniseries I suppose I was a likely choice.
My concept was a generational family of Park Rangers charged with keeping the ‘hidden folk’ in line, facing a crisis when a drained reservoir exposed an ancient woodland and released its angry Elementals. My log line was, ‘Hunting fairies with pickup truck and cattle prod’.
Sky took in the pitches, gave them all equal consideration, and handed the commission to Elisabeth Murdoch’s company. In retrospect I’m thinking that they were more interested in Buffy’s strong female representation, and the audience that would bring with it, than in a fantasy show per se.
By then the idea had taken life to an extent that I couldn’t let it go. Of course I couldn’t, or it wouldn’t have been worth pursuing in the first place. I had a much bigger plan than you’ll see in the pitch document, which is just the start of a conversation.
Eventually I drew on the work to create a novella for one of my Christmas chapbooks, covering much of the ground of the original pilot. It’s out there, you can buy it. The rest lurks under the surface; waiting, like the story’s Elementals, for the chance to be let loose.
Or to be optioned. That works, too.
You’ll find that the above link takes you not to a script or a treatment, but to the Subterranean Press page for a Hard Case-style novella titled The Next Thing You See When You Die. Here’s why:
Risen was a pitch that I made as part of the development deal I had with Bruckheimer TV, back when we were making Eleventh Hour for CBS. The logline: while a former undercover officer struggles to reconnect with his home life, a young woman from his criminal past seeks vengeance for the ghosts of those he betrayed.
I’ll be honest, out of all the material we discussed it was the one I really hoped they’d go for. But after two tries I backed off and we went with something else, which in the end the studio didn’t like. But that’s another story.
This one stayed with me and the only way to shake off the spell was to write a spec pilot. No one wanted it, no one was waiting for it, I just needed to do it. Nothing much happened until Simon Maxwell at Red Arrow read the script and fell for it. He took Risen to MIPCOM in Cannes and pitched it hard to a number of potential partners. I was in Lisbon picking up the European Science TV Award for my Silent Witness when I learned that we were moving into a deal with ABC Signature, a production arm of Disney’s ABC Network (and yes, it was just as exciting as that all makes it sound).
Things moved fast. Notes and rewrites with Signature VP David Marko made the script tighter, better, without changing anything of its essential character. I developed a 13-hour series arc and took steps to renew my 0-1 visa. We were lined up for a summer slot, a time of year when the pressure and the competition for new shows were felt to be less intense. For production I’d be working with Henrik Bastin’s Fabrik Entertainment, makers of Bosch. We just needed ABC President Paul Lee’s signoff and we’d have our green light.
The call came from David. He began with, “Steve, it’s not good news.”
As I understood it, Steven Spielberg’s Amblin Entertainment had a show for which he’d been seeking one of the prized winter network slots, without success. So they’d lowered their sights and gone looking for a summer slot, and Paul Lee gave them ours.
When I advise new writers that they must learn to bounce, this is why.
I’m still gripped by my concept, still won’t let it go. So when Subterranean’s Bill Schafer asked if I might have an idea for a 30,000 word novella, I had a ready reply. Stories want to be told.
And now I have another one that I can tell. About the time I was bumped by Steven Spielberg.
The British and American iterations of Eleventh Hour were radically different experiences for me. I quit the UK show a week before shooting began, after a long wrangle over the difference between research-based drama and junk science. I’m not sure which was the last straw; the dialogue rewrite of my material by a novice, or the proposed ‘race’ between me and two other writers to get to a finished script for the last available slot on the show I’d created. I made that one easier for them by narrowing the field.
The show as broadcast received a damning review from former Chief Government Scientific Advisor Robert May in the Times Higher Education Supplement. Lord May cited the ‘clunky script’ and the melodramatic misrepresentation of the science, and I dropped him a line to tell him I agreed on both counts.
The script here (code CFX to unlock the file) is the one that I delivered for the UK with my dialogue intact, and concerns the trail of heartbreak in an attempt to achieve the first human clone. It’s an achievement long sought by a succession of fringe figures and self-publicists, outliers to the scientific community, and I saw it as representing the masculine urge to exercise control over reproduction. Among other things, in rewriting me they made my Bad Science Man a woman.
And that, I thought, was that, until a couple of years on I had a call to get myself down to London and meet with KristieAnne Reed and Jonathan Littman of JBTV. Jerry Bruckheimer had bought the format rights; slow as I am, it took a while for me to grasp how much they wanted me on board. What followed showed me how your worst experiences can so often lead to your best.
Until the streamers broke up the pattern there was a US pitching season, a couple of intensively-scheduled summer weeks where executives from networks and cable providers would hear back-to-back presentations from producers and prospective showrunners. From these live pitches they’d commission a certain number of scripts. From those scripts they’d finance a smaller number of pilots. A select few of those would be given an episode order for maybe thirteen hours with an option for a ‘back nine’ to make up a full twenty-two. This would trigger staffing season as the chosen shows hired their writers. As those shows moved into production for broadcast later in the year, pitching season would roll around again.
What I’ve posted here are the notes for a live presentation based on my novel White Bizango. My producers were Noreen Halpern, Simon Maxwell, and Vadim Jean for a week of meetings in 2012. We covered NBC, A&E, Fox, ABC and Sony. They put me up at the Mondrian on Sunset Boulevard (now the Sunset Tower, with less weird decor), right next to a dog park donated to the city by star of silent Westerns William S Hart.
Pitching across several seasons I worked on three US network shows as writer or creator and sold another three pilots that were paid for but not produced. Not a big score if you’re a John Wells or a David Kelly, but it’ll do for me. This one made it no further than the scripted stage but I loved the entire experience. I loved the ones that worked out and the ones that didn’t. It was a good time, working with good people.


